The Indie Squeeze: Why Rights Matter More When Commissioning Gets Tough
UK television production is not in freefall, but the market has become harder and less forgiving — particularly for smaller independents. When commissions are scarcer and cash is tighter, the rights around a programme can matter as much as the production margin on the first deal.
UK television production is not in freefall, but the market has become harder and less forgiving — particularly for smaller independents. When commissions are scarcer and cash is tighter, the rights around a programme can matter as much as the production margin on the first deal.
A tighter market, even where headline spend looks resilient
Ofcom’s Media Nations 2026 reports that UK TV production revenues edged up to £3.55 billion in 2025, but income from UK primary commissions fell again, to £1.65 billion. International primary commissions rose to £1.27 billion, while UK and international secondary-rights revenues were £334 million and £300 million respectively. The broadcaster picture is nuanced: excluding sport, PSB first-run UK-originated spend rose 2% in 2025, even as commercial broadcaster revenues fell from £4.98 billion to £4.83 billion. This is not a story of every broadcaster cutting every budget. It is one of continuing pressure on domestic commissioning, shifting priorities and less room for error.
For smaller producers, the cash consequences are stark. An Indielab analysis of Companies House accounts for 203 active small indies, reported in September 2026, found median reserves of £42,000; 56% had seen reserves fall over the three-year period examined, and Indielab projected that 40% could be at risk of closure within two years if current trends continued. That is a projection, not an inevitability, but it shows how little buffer some businesses now have. Separately, an Oliver & Ohlbaum report commissioned by Everyone TV found that 76% of the independent production groups commissioned by PSBs in 2025 were small producers.
Commissioning pressure becomes a balance-sheet issue
Development and overhead do not stop when greenlights slow down. Producers still have to generate ideas, secure access or underlying rights, engage writers and talent, prepare materials, build budgets and keep development and business-affairs capability in place.
HMRC’s current Audio-Visual Expenditure Credit guidance describes development as speculative work undertaken to determine whether a programme is commercially feasible, and distinguishes it from pre-production after a decision to proceed. Development expenditure is not core expenditure for AVEC. Commercially, that leaves the producer carrying risk before there is a commission to finance the programme.
The development deal therefore matters. Who is funding the work? Is that funding recoupable, and from what? Who owns the materials? How long is the idea tied up? What happens if the commissioner passes or changes strategy? A modest development fee can be poor value if it sterilises valuable IP for too long; producer-funded development can be equally damaging if there is no discipline about when to stop spending.
Why rights become more valuable when commissions are scarce
Pact’s 2025 Census, covering 2024, found secondary-rights revenue rose 17.2% to £510 million, while UK rights income increased sharply to £303 million. Pact linked that growth to producers focusing on secondary rights as primary commissions slowed.
The legal framework matters. For qualifying independent productions within the PSB regime, Ofcom’s revised 2025 guidance says the underlying principle is that producers should retain rights unless they are explicitly sold. It distinguishes the broadcaster’s primary licence from secondary rights, which may include international distribution, format sales and later exploitation on other channels or on-demand services. Ofcom also says there should be no automatic bundling of primary and secondary rights, although a PSB can seek additional rights through commercial negotiation.
That is not a universal rule that every producer always owns every right. The regulatory regime has a defined scope, broadcaster Terms of Trade differ, and non-PSB or non-qualifying commissions may operate differently. The contract remains critical.
Rights only have value if they can be exploited
Retention on paper is not revenue. A producer needs to know whether a programme has a realistic international, format, library or ancillary life, and whether the agreed licence, exclusivity and holdbacks leave room to pursue it.
Pact’s latest TV Exports Report put UK TV exports at a record £2.02 billion in 2024/25, up 10.9% year on year. Finished-programme sales remained the largest category at £1.069 billion; format revenues rose 13% to £244 million; and library sales accounted for 44% of sales. Older content can become valuable again when buyers are looking for lower-cost ways to fill schedules and services.
Territory, media, licence period, exclusivity, holdbacks, extensions, recommissioning rights, format control, clips, free ad-supported streaming television (FAST) and AVOD use, and revenue shares can all affect long-term value. The new Pact/5 Terms of Trade, effective from March 2026 for qualifying unscripted PSB commissions, illustrate the point: the initial licence period is three years and producers retain 100% of international sales revenue. Those terms are not a template for the rest of the market, but they show how apparently technical provisions move value.
Negotiate the whole economics, not just the headline fee
The first question is cash. Does the payment schedule fund the production when expenditure falls due, or is the producer effectively financing part of the gap? What happens if delivery slips, approvals are delayed or a final payment is held back? If there is a deficit, who funds it and what rights or recoupment position are exchanged for that finance?
The second is ownership and control. Is the chain of title clean enough for future sales? Are the underlying rights broad enough for the extensions that are genuinely relevant to the property? If a distributor is appointed, what are the term, commission, expense cap, recoupment waterfall and approval rights, and when do unsold rights revert?
The third is time. A right returned after the commercial opportunity has passed may be worth little. Exclusivity, holdbacks, options, first-negotiation provisions and recommissioning windows should be tested against the likely sales cycle, not treated as boilerplate.
None of this means resisting every broad rights grant. Sometimes a wider package is what makes an ambitious programme financeable, and sometimes the commissioner is best placed to exploit particular rights. The question is whether the producer understands what is being given up, what it receives in return and whether the remaining rights still support future value.
The commission is only one part of the asset
Rights cannot rescue a weak programme or replace sensible cash management. But they can diversify revenue, improve the economics of a successful title and create value after the first licence has ended.
When development is expensive and greenlights are harder won, the commissioning agreement should therefore be negotiated not only as the document that gets a programme made, but as the document that determines what remains of the asset afterwards.